Dungannon | Royal School Dungannon | Matamata Swifts | Heybridge Swifts F.C. | Dungannon (horse) | Arthur Hill-Trevor, 3rd Viscount Dungannon |
He returned to local football with Portadown, Distillery then Dungannon Swifts before retiring from the game due to a long–term ankle injury.
On 10 December 2008, Dungannon Swifts manager John Cunningham confirmed that McCafferty would be joining the Swifts squad, but was unavailable to play until the transfer window opened in January.