Cardiff RFC | Oxford University RFC | Newport RFC | Swansea RFC | Llanelli RFC | Pontypridd RFC | Glasgow Academicals RFC | Pontypool RFC | London Welsh RFC | St. Peters RFC | St. George’s Hospital Medical School RFC | Hawick RFC | Aberavon RFC | South Wales Police RFC | Neath RFC | Bedwas RFC | Penarth RFC | Medicals RFC | Watsonians RFC | Vienna Celtic RFC | Tylorstown RFC | St. George's Hospital Medical School RFC | Southend RFC | Shannon RFC | Selkirk RFC | San Francisco Golden Gate RFC | RFC Liège | Percy Park RFC | Old Illtydians RFC | Mountain Ash RFC |
Although a product of the university system, Nicholl was well known for his hard style of play, and survived until the end of the season but was replaced by Llwynypia's Dick Hellings in 1897.