The highest score during this period was in a Southern League match against New Brompton on 7 November 1896, which "the Saints" won 8–3 with a hat-trick from Willie Naughton.
The Saints showed their superiority with a 5–1 victory, with goals from Jack Farrell (2), Alf Littlehales and Willie Naughton, all of whom had joined the club from Stoke, and Joe Turner, another summer recruit from Staffordshire.
Willie Nelson | Willie Mays | Willie Horton | Willie Dixon | Willie Brown | Willie Colón | Willie Brown (politician) | Willie Revillame | Willie Miller | Willie Stargell | Willie Perdomo | Willie Pep | Willie Mitchell | Willie Thorne | Willie Sutton | Willie Roaf | Willie | Steamboat Willie | Shotgun Willie | Willie Worsley | Willie Wells | Willie Totten | Willie Savage | Willie Redmond | Willie Randolph | Willie Pearse | Willie John McBride | Willie Hernández | Willie Ferguson | Willie Crawford |