The 28 pre-expansion teams were each represented by a classic era equivalent, which ranged from 1960 (Philadelphia Eagles) to 1986 (New York Giants), although all players identified as number-only.
New York City | New York | The New York Times | New York University | York | New York Yankees | Buffalo, New York | 1986 | Rochester, New York | New York Giants | New York Stock Exchange | New York Mets | Albany, New York | New York State Assembly | San Francisco Giants | Syracuse, New York | New York State Senate | New York City Subway | New York Philharmonic | York University | the season | New York Jets | New York Public Library | Lake Placid, New York | New York Rangers | Mayor of New York City | New York Supreme Court | Governor of New York | Archbishop of York | University at Buffalo, The State University of New York |