Greg Adams of Allmusic called the album's ninth track "Rotten Little Song" to evoke the vocal performance of Shirley Temple because of its "la la" chorus". Adams reviewed All About a Feeling and gave it three out of five stars, stating, "Fargo's brand of upbeat and accessible country is the sort of music that brought the genre such tremendous mainstream success from the '70s onward.
The Feeling | Feeling Good | The Man of Feeling | The Feeling Good Handbook | Hooked on a Feeling | Feeling So Blue | Feeling Good: The New Mood Therapy | Feeling B | You've Lost That Loving Feeling | You've Lost That Lovin' Feeling | That Sinking Feeling (1980 film) | That Sinking Feeling | Peaceful Easy Feeling | Once More with Feeling | Music, Thought, and Feeling | More Than a Feeling | Miss Smilla's Feeling for Snow | I've Got a Feeling | It's a Great Feeling | If You're Feeling Sinister | Feeling So Real | Can't Fight This Feeling |