However, it was her regular supporting role as Grace Polk on the series Joan of Arcadia, alongside Amber Tamblyn, which has attracted most attention.
Christopher Stipp of Asitecalledfred.com praised the film writing that "the combination of Moore's directing/writing and of Jeremy Boreing's writing with Levi and Amber Tamblyn's performances should prove to be the reason why this movie stands above most of the other independent fare that passes as film".
The first book was made into a movie in 2005, starring Alexis Bledel as Lena, Amber Tamblyn as Tibby, America Ferrera as Carmen, and Blake Lively as Bridget.
Amber | Amber Tamblyn | Amber Benson | amber | Amber Lee Ettinger | AMBER Alert | Amber Riley | Baltic amber | Ian Tamblyn | Amber Sherlock | Amber Rubarth | Amber Road | Amber (performer) | Amber O'Shea | Amber MacArthur | Amber Lawrence | Amber Holt | Amber Holland | Amber Dhara | Amber Chia | Amber Alert | The Hare with Amber Eyes | Tamblyn | Rob and Amber | Jess Tamblyn | Corwin (The Chronicles of Amber) | Amber Theoharis | Amber Reeves | Amber Radio | Amber Pacific |
Hagan next appeared in the direct-to-DVD Warner Bros. comedy feature Spring Breakdown (which was released on June 2, 2009), alongside Parker Posey and Saturday Night Live cast members Amy Poehler and Rachel Dratch; she plays Truvy, the friend of a college co-ed (Amber Tamblyn) who is also the daughter of a powerful senator.