Many of the top headliners in the U.S. have performed at Carolines, including Paul Reubens, Jerry Seinfeld, Jay Leno, Bill Hicks, Andrew Dice Clay, Gilbert Gottfried, Andy Borowitz, Joy Behar, Jon Stewart, Robin Williams, Colin Quinn, Chris Rock, Norm Macdonald, Elayne Boosler, Michael Richards, Richard Belzer, Chris Rush and Mitch Hedberg.
The series featured Benincasa in a bathtub with various comedic personalities, including Reggie Watts, Jonathan Ames, and Andy Borowitz.
Andy Warhol | The Andy Griffith Show | Andy Murray | Andy Roddick | Andy Sheppard | Andy Goldsworthy | Andy Williams | Andy Griffith | Horace Andy | Andy Sturmer | Andy Reid | Andy Gibb | Andy Devine | Andy Summers | Andy Dick | Andy McCoy | Andy Goodman | Andy | Andy McCluskey | Andy Hertzfeld | Andy Grammer | Andy García | Andy C | Andy Samberg | Andy Montañez | Andy Lau | Andy Kaufman | Andy Katz | Andy Hopper | Amos 'n' Andy |