The men all came from Ballymaguigan and played for St. Trea's GFC Ballymaguigan.
Glasgow Caledonian University GAC | Kilcoo GAC | Banagher GAC | Ballymaguigan GAC | St. Trea's GFC Ballymaguigan | St. Mary's GAC Banagher | St Mary's GAC Banagher | Slaughtmanus GAC | Pearse Óg GAC | O'Brien's GAC | John Mitchel's GAC | Hunterstown Rovers GAC | Glenullin GAC | Glack GAC | Gać | Foreglen GAC | Erin's Own GAC Lavey | Clonduff GAC | Caltra GAC | Ballymaguigan |
Ballymaguigan's Jim McKeever won the inaugural award in 1958, while Henry Downey of the Lavey club received player of the year for his performances in helping Derry win the 1993 All-Ireland Senior Football Championship.