Candice Bergen | Candice Miller | For the Bible Tells Me So | Candice Wiggins | Candice Olson | Candice Michelle | Something Tells Me (Something's Gonna Happen Tonight) | Candice Rialson | Candice Nelson |
Candice Olson ("Divine Design", "Candice Tells All") served as a judge for seasons 5 and 6; starting with season 7, a third rotating judge was brought in to fill the spot left by Olson.