In 2007, the band released a 3-song, colored 7" vinyl record, along with a 6-track CD titled Elephant Elephant, which was released in a limited edition of 1,111 copies on Jason's label (11 records); it quickly sold out.
John Evelyn | Evelyn Waugh | Richard Evelyn Byrd | Evelyn Glennie | Evelyn | Evelyn Holt | Evelyn (film) | Evelyn Laye | Evelyn Baring, 1st Earl of Cromer | Evelyn Baring | Evelyn Tubb | Evelyn Robert de Rothschild | Evelyn Fox Keller | Evelyn Evelyn | Evelyn Beatrice Longman | Evelyn Baring, 1st Baron Howick of Glendale | Evelyn Ankers | Mount Evelyn, Victoria | Mary Evelyn Parker | John Evelyn's Diary | Evelyn Insam | Evelyn Hooker | Evelyn Frechette | Evelyn Eaton | Evelyn "Champagne" King | William Arthur Evelyn | Sir John Evelyn | Mount Evelyn | Judith Evelyn | Grace Evelyn Pickford |
"Love Will Tear Us Apart", "Elephant Elephant", "Have You Seen My Sister Evelyn?", and "Sandy's Theme" (with added vocals and under the title "Sandy Fishnets") also appear on their 2010 debut album, Evelyn Evelyn, all of which were re-recorded for the album.
Musicians Amanda Palmer (of The Dresden Dolls) and Jason Webley formed the band Evelyn Evelyn in 2007, and together wrote a concept album based on the fictional story of conjoined twins "Evelyn Neville and Evelyn Neville".