The band released its fifth album, Give Us Barabbas, in 2004, which was more of a collection of lost tracks - opening with the "Ballad of Jody Frosty".
Barabbas | Something's Gotta Give | Give Peace a Chance | Something's Gotta Give (film) | Something's Got to Give | Give Us a Clue | You Get What You Give | I Can't Give You Anything but Love, Baby | Give My Regards to Davy | Give My Regards to Broadway | Give Me All Your Luvin' | Give It Up or Turnit a Loose | Give It 2 Me | Never Gonna Give You Up | Never Give Up: The 20th Century Odyssey of Herbert Zipper | I Give It a Year | I Can't Give You Anything But Love | Give Us This Day | Give Up the Ghost | Give Me Convenience or Give Me Death | Frankly, my dear, I don't give a damn | Don't Give Up Your Day Job Productions | Something's Gotta Give (movie) | Something's Gotta Give (LeAnn Rimes song) | Never, Never Gonna Give Ya Up | Love Isn't Love ('Til You Give It Away) | John and Yoko in 1969 recording ''Give Peace a Chance | I Won't Give Up on You | If I Give My Heart to You | Got to Give It Up |
Specifically, when the crowd is asked whether Jesus or Barabbas should be spared, they must all join the call "Give us Barabbas!" (a priest absolves them from any guilt for so doing).