Following his playing career, Schlueter became a dedicated coach and supporter of all youth and high school sports in Scottsdale, Arizona, and Chaparral, New Mexico.
Jay-Z | Jay Leno | The Tonight Show with Jay Leno | Alan Jay Lerner | Stephen Jay Gould | John Jay | Jay Sean | Jay Gould | Jay-Jay Okocha | Jay Farrar | Jay Mohr | Jay Chou | Jay Feaster | The Jay Leno Show | Jay McInerney | Jay Leonhart | Jay Lane | Jay and the Americans | Jay Nixon | Jay Inslee | Jay | George Jay Gould I | Blue Jay | Tony Jay | John Jay College of Criminal Justice | Jay Ward | Jay Kinney | Vee-Jay Records | Joshua Jay | Jay Rosen |
On December 23, 1974, May was traded to the Baltimore Orioles, along with minor league outfielder Jay Schlueter for infielder/outfielder Enos Cabell and second baseman Rob Andrews.