She later competed in New York, winning the Miss New York USA 1994 title, and representing New York in the Miss USA 1994 pageant held in South Padre Island, Texas on February 11, 1994.
•
Gareis competed in her first beauty pageant in 1992 when she placed second runner-up at Miss Pennsylvania USA.
•
Gareis placed in the top six of the nationally televised pageant, which was won by Lu Parker of South Carolina.
Jennifer Lopez | Jennifer Love Hewitt | Jennifer Aniston | Jennifer Saunders | Jennifer Jones | Jennifer Hudson | Jennifer Hale | Jennifer Egan | Jennifer Bartlett | Jennifer Warnes | Jennifer Morrison | Jennifer Granholm | Jennifer Tipton | Jennifer Tilly | Jennifer Rush | Jennifer Harman | Jennifer's Body | Jennifer O'Neill | Jennifer Hawkins | Jennifer Connelly | Jennifer Lawrence | Jennifer Ehle | Jennifer Beals | Jennifer Warren | Jennifer Simpson | Jennifer L. Knox | Jennifer Kirk | Jennifer Kimball | Jennifer Johnson | Jennifer Holliday |