On February 22, 2012 Godderz, Rob Terry and Rudy Switchblade defeated Jason Wayne and Shiloh Jonze in a handicap match to win the OVW Southern Tag Team Championship.
•
He then returned the next season on Big Brother 13 again with a Pandora's Box offering a shopping spree with Tori Spelling.
•
However, Rachel, was locked inside Pandora's Box with Godderz for a shopping spree of "Mr. Pec-tacular" merchandise, while the rest of the house earned the shopping spree with Tori Spelling.
On 14 February edition of Impact he teamed up with The Blossom Twins (Hannah and Holly) to face the team of Tara, Jessie, and Gail Kim.
Jessie Godderz | Jessie | Lake Jessie Township, Itasca County, Minnesota | Lake Jessie Township | Jessie Penn-Lewis | Jessie Matthews | Jessie (TV series) | Jessie Foster | Kim & Jessie | Jessie Ward | Jessie Tuggle | Jessie Rae Scott | Jessie Malakouti | Jessie Farrell | Jessie Armstead | Young Jessie | Jessie Williams | Jessie Willcox Smith | Jessie White's house in Lendinara | Jessie White Mario | Jessie Vasey | Jessie Tompkins | Jessie Stephen | Jessie (song) | Jessie's Girl | Jessie Rooke | Jessie Redmon Fauset | Jessie Pavelka | Jessie McTavish | Jessie Duarte |
On October 20, 2013, during the Countdown to Bound for Glory pre-show "Mr. Olympia" Phil Heath made his TNA debut, accompanying The BroMans (Jessie Godderz and Robbie E) to the ring for their tag team gauntlet match, which they won and later on in the night, accompanied them to their TNA World Tag Team Championship match against Gunner and James Storm.
On the Countdown to Bound for Glory Pre-show The BroMans (Jessie Godderz and Robbie E) with "Mr. Olympia" Phil Heath defeated Chavo Guerrero and Hernandez, Bad Influence (Christopher Daniels and Kazarian) and Eric Young and Joseph Park to earn a TNA World Tag Team Championship match on the Pay-per view, The Bro Mans defeated Storm and Gunner to win the TNA World Tag Team Championships.
Robbie E started allying himself with Jessie Godderz on the May 2 episode of Impact Wrestling, where they teamed with Joey Ryan in a handicap match against Rob Terry, which the team lost after Robbie and Jessie walked out on Ryan and left him to be pinned.