At the outbreak of World War I professional football was suspended, and McFadden joined the 17th Battalion Middlesex Regiment, the "Footballers' Battalion", along with 40 other Orient players and staff.
Middlesex | regiment | Middlesex County, Massachusetts | Middlesex County | Middlesex Hospital | Middlesex University | Parachute Regiment (United Kingdom) | Regiment | Seventh Regiment Armory | Parachute Regiment | Royal New Zealand Infantry Regiment | Gloucestershire Regiment | Devonshire Regiment | The Royal Canadian Regiment | Royal Newfoundland Regiment | Middlesex County, New Jersey | Essex Regiment | East Yorkshire Regiment | Royal Sussex Regiment | Royal Anglian Regiment | King's Own Royal Border Regiment | Cheshire Regiment | 5th Cavalry Regiment | South Lancashire Regiment | Royal Tank Regiment | Royal Lincolnshire Regiment | Middlesex County, Ontario | Duke of Wellington's Regiment | Canadian Airborne Regiment | Royal Norfolk Regiment |
; he wrote the histories of the Royal Warwickshire and the Middlesex Regiments; and he edited the first volume on the manuscripts of Lord De L'isle and Dudley in the publications of the Historical MSS.