Procter & Gamble | Nathan Bedford Forrest | Nathan Lane | Nathan Hale | Nathan Milstein | Starboy Nathan | Nathan | Nathan Fillion | Nathan the Wise | Nathan Englander | Nathan's Famous | Nathan Mayer Rothschild | Nathan East | Nathan Appleton | Lionel Nathan de Rothschild | Nathan Scott | Nathan Phillips Square | Nathan Phillips | Nathan Lawr | Nathan Carter | Nathan Barley | John Nathan-Turner | James Gamble Rogers | William Nathan Wrighte Hewett | Nathan Zuckerman | Nathan Stoltzfus | Nathan Rennie | Nathan (prophet) | Nathan Parseghian | Nathan Mumm |
Harry Connick Jr., Ashley Judd, Nathan Gamble, Cozi Zuehlsdorff, Kris Kristofferson, Morgan Freeman and Austin Stowell all reprise their roles from the first film, while Taylor Blackwell, Denisea Wilson, Denis Arndt, Lee Karlinsky, Julia Jordan and Bethany Hamilton join the cast.