Randy Brecker | Jason Mraz | Randy Travis | Jason Alexander | David Jason | Randy Stonehill | Jason Robards | Randy Quaid | Jason Grimshaw | Randy Lerner | Jason Kidd | Jason Kenney | Jason Isaacs | Jason Statham | Jason Newsted | Randy Johnson | Jason | Randy Jackson | Randy Bachman | Jason Priestley | Jason Aldean | Randy Couture | Randy Kuhl | Jason Scott Lee | Jason Schwartzman | Jason Mewes | Randy Moss | Randy Crawford | Jason Ritter | Jason Donovan |
It featured Randy and Jason Sklar of Cheap Seats going on a trip all the way to the National Baseball Hall of Fame in Cooperstown on a campaign to get José "The Utilityman" Oquendo inducted for his versatility to play any position on the baseball field.
For this edition of the game, the "Phone A Complete Stranger" lifeline was replaced with a chance to ask an ESPN expert (either Howie Schwab or the Sklar Twins) for assistance.