Emmy Award | Grammy Award | Tony Award | Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film | National Book Award | Daytime Emmy Award | Juno Award | Obie Award | Golden Globe Award | Primetime Emmy Award | Drama Desk Award | César Award | Academy Award for Best Picture | Edgar Award | Konex Award | Academy Award for Best Visual Effects | Academy Award for Best Original Song | Eisner Award | Latin Grammy Award | Hugo Award | Peabody Award | Grammy Award for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance | award | Academy Award for Best Actress | National Film Award for Best Feature Film in Malayalam | BAFTA Award for Best Film | Award | Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress | Academy Award for Best Cinematography | Cy Young Award |
Eight Kelton novels, Buffalo Wagons, The Day the Cowboys Quit, The Time It Never Rained, Eyes of the Hawk, Slaughter, The Far Canyon, Many a River and The Way of the Coyote, have won Spur Awards from the Western Writers of America.
Hamilton's short story contribution, The Guns of William Longley, won the 1967 Western Writers of America Spur Award for best short material.
Hoffman won the Western Writers of America Spur Award for her novel The Valdez Horses (Doubleday, 1967).