Music journalist and critic Toby Creswell included "Into My Arms" in his book 1001 Songs: The Great Songs of All Time and the Artists, Stories and Secrets Behind Them, in which he attributed the song's melancholic lyrics to the break-up of Cave's long-term relationship with Viviane Carneiro and his subsequent brief relationship and break-up with English musician PJ Harvey.
After remaining dormant for six months, Phillip Keir acquired the rights to publish it in 1987 in partnership with his wife Lisa-Belle Furhagen and his friend Toby Creswell.
Toby Keith | Ryan Toby | Creswell Crags | Toby Wright | Toby Gad | Toby | Toby Young | Toby Williams | Toby Gerhart | Toby Cockerell | Creswell | Toby Wilkinson | Toby Stephens | Toby Litt | Toby Creswell | Who's Your Daddy? (Toby Keith song) | Toby the Tram Engine | Toby Schmitz | Toby Nixon | Toby Kebbell | Toby Jones | Toby Jepson | Ronald Toby | Uncle Toby's | Toby Whithouse | Toby Tyler | Toby Truslove | ''Toby the Tram Engine'' | Toby Swift | Toby Robins |
Critic Toby Creswell described Circus Animals as, "a really extraordinary piece of work, as though John Steinbeck, Henry Lawson, Manning Clarke and Jerry Lee Lewis formed a band."