She made her Broadway theatre debut in 1917 and the following year appeared with her actress sister, Faire Binney(1898–1957), in the Maurice Tourneur silent film, Sporting Life based on the play by Cecil Raleigh and Seymour Hicks.
Lake Constance | Council of Constance | Constance Bennett | Constance Markievicz | Constance Kamii | Marcus Binney | Constance Towers | Constance Baker Motley | Bishopric of Constance | Angela Constance | Constance Steinkuehler | Constance of York | Constance McCashin | Constance Jablonski | Constance Worth | Constance Whitney Warren | Constance of Arles | Constance McLaughlin Green | Constance Kent | Constance Keene | Constance Crawley | Bernold of Constance | Peace of Constance | Emissaries of the church of ''"Moldovlahia"'' to the Council of Constance | Edward William Binney | Constance Wu | Constance Villiers-Stuart | Constance Talmadge | Constance of Sicily | Constance of Aragon |
Erstwhile Susan is only one of two films by Constance Binney that has survived in a complete form, the other being The Case of Becky (1921).