Paine was a member of the Union League, the Merchants, and the New York Athletics Clubs.
Marylebone Cricket Club | Lancashire County Cricket Club | Sierra Club | club | Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band | Club Brugge K.V. | Somerset County Cricket Club | Sport Club Corinthians Paulista | Glamorgan County Cricket Club | Hampshire County Cricket Club | Nottinghamshire County Cricket Club | Richmond Football Club | Gloucestershire County Cricket Club | Cornwall County Cricket Club | Kent County Cricket Club | Club Nacional de Football | Cambridge University Cricket Club | Collingwood Football Club | Yorkshire County Cricket Club | sports club | Essendon Football Club | Port Adelaide Football Club | Jockey Club | Club Atlético River Plate | Carlton Football Club | St Kilda Football Club | Racing Club de Avellaneda | Manhattan Theatre Club | Club Olimpia | Surrey County Cricket Club |
He was a member of Delta Kappa Epsilon, Down Town Association, Jekyll Island Club, Merchants Club of New York, Metropolitan Club of New York, New England Society, New York Yacht Club, Players Club of New York, Republican Club of New York, Riding Club of New York, Seawanhaka Corinthian Yacht Club, Skull and Bones, South Side Sportsmen's Club, Union League Club of New York and the Whist Club of New York.