Alongside former teammates Johnny Damon and Edgar Rentería, Timlin made an appearance on the TV cartoon Arthur, providing his voice for the Elwood City Grebes pitcher "Winlin."
Mike Tyson | Mike Oldfield | Mike Harris | Mike Nattrass | Mike Leigh | Mike Watt | Mike Mignola | Mike Gordon | Mike | Mike Nichols | Mike Rutherford | Mike Wallace | Mike Stern | Mike Huckabee | Mike Ditka | Mike Figgis | Mike Rowe | Mike Reid | Mike Portnoy | Mike Piazza | Mike Mills | Mike Varney | Mike Mansfield | Mike Easley | Mike Douglas | Mike Wallace (journalist) | Mike Viola | Mike Howlett | Mike Curb | Mike Chapman |
On June 2, 2005 Callahan upset some listeners during interviews with Red Sox CEO Larry Lucchino and relief pitcher Mike Timlin discussing the upcoming visit of Carson Kressley and the cast from Queer Eye at Fenway Park.
His days in Seattle were short as he was traded to the Toronto Blue Jays for Paul Spoljaric and Mike Timlin on July 31, 1997.
Over the years, some of the most notable players to wear a Medicine Hat uniform include Chris Carpenter, David Wells, Lloyd Moseby, Fred Manrique, John Cerutti, Gustavo Chacín, Mike Timlin, and Jay Gibbons, who won the league's Triple Crown in 1998.